We tend to talk about artificial intelligence as if the principal question is simply: What can machines do? Or What should we let them do? But there is a far deeper and more urgent question: Who are we as human beings? Because until we know what makes us distinct from machines, all the “should we” debates about AI are premature.
A recent Fox News story described a new app that lets users “text with Jesus” and other Bible figures via AI-generation. Another recent headline showed a reporter’s supposed conversation with AI avatar claiming to be one of the deceased students from the tragic Parkland High School shooting in Florida. These aren’t quirky tech stories, they reflect a growing confusion about identity, agency, and dignity in the age of machine intelligence.
The Darwinist legacy looms large in this discussion. For generations our culture has been fed the lie that humans are just advanced animals, emerged by chance without any special status. If that’s true — if we’re just flesh-machines — then AI becomes simply a higher-powered flesh-machine and the line between man and machine quickly dissolves. But if we are more — if we bear image, purpose, moral capacity — then AI must be treated accordingly (not idolized or outsourced).
So the question we must answer is: Are humans merely “meat machines” or are we something more — created with meaning, dignity and purpose? Until we answer that, all the other AI questions — from labor to art, from ethics to politics — are buried in deeper failures of self-understanding. The rush to delegate human tasks to AI — creativity, relationship, decision-making — often reflects a belief that human beings are interchangeable parts in a machine-society. Instead of celebrating human dignity, we risk treating people like components subject to optimization.
In short: the age of AI doesn’t just demand new rules for new tools — it demands clarity about where humans have come from and what we are for. We are created “Imago Dei” – in the image of God, and God alone gives us our value, purpose, and identity. When a society forgets that, it hands over its future to machines. And once machines become the standard of “who counts,” human life loses its privileged place. That’s not progress. That is a tragedy.
The Phyllis Schlafly Report never rests in the search for important topics that we must understand and communicate to those in the culture us. Visit PhyllisSchlafly.com today and sign up for our emails and alerts so you don’t miss the biggest worldview issues facing America today. Again that’s PhyllisSchlafly.com. Thanks for listening and join us tomorrow for the Phyllis Schlafly Report.
