There’s a debate happening in Missouri, and in states across the country, over a question that sounds simple on the surface: when should school board elections be held?
Many conservatives and in the Show Me State, and some legislators in the General Assembly, suggest moving some school board elections from their traditional spring dates to the November general election ballot. This is a worthy question to ask!
The argument for November elections is straightforward. Spring and off-year school board races routinely draw less than 20% voter turnout. That small, predictable electorate has long been a gift to teachers unions and activist groups who know how to mobilize their voters in low-stakes elections. Moving these races to November floods the ballot with more voices and theoretically dilutes the influence of special interest spending. For conservative parents frustrated by what has been happening in classrooms —gender ideology, age-inappropriate curriculum, and hostility to parental rights — this feels like a fix. And there’s something to it.
But the practical results tells a more complicated story. Higher turnout is a double-edged sword. Liberal voters and teachers unions turn out in November too, and they’ve been running organized local campaigns for decades. And, frankly, in November, significant numbers of voters never make it to the bottom of a long ballot where school board races typically appear. Higher overall turnout doesn’t guarantee conservative school board victories.
Here’s the truth: Moving an election to November is a structural change, not a cultural one. It may put more eyeballs on the ballot, but it can’t guarantee those eyes belong to informed voters. A parent who has never attended a school board meeting, never read a curriculum proposal, and never spoken at a public comment period doesn’t suddenly become an engaged watchdog just because the election moved to November.
The real answer — the only answer that produces change — is informed, active, and locally engaged citizens who treat school board oversight as a serious civic responsibility. Higher turnout helps, so reform the calendar if you can. But there’s no shortcut for showing up and staying informed about exactly who is making decisions about your children. Don’t wait for the calendar to save the classroom.
Stay informed and get involved at PhyllisSchlafly.com. Sign up for our emails and alerts, again at PhyllisSchlafly.com, and join us again for the Phyllis Schlafly Report.
