Last month, a federal court in New York delivered a landmark medical malpractice verdict that is likely to be a turning point in the national debate over so-called “transgender” medicine for minors. A jury award $2 million to a young woman, now aged 22, who underwent a double mastectomy at the age of 16. Fox Varian is one of the many individuals now called “detransitioners” who are leaving behind the notion of identifying as the opposite sex. The problem for these young people like Fox, however, is that permanent alterations leave them with a lifetime of consequences.
Evidence presented at the trial showed that both Varian’s psychologist and surgeon ignored important mental health factors, overlooked doubts expressed by Fox’s family, and failed to follow informed consent! The jury concluded that these failures amounted to $1.6 million for pain and suffering, and another $400,000 for future medical expenses. This case is rightly recognized as the first, but hardly the last, successful trial against so-called “gender affirming care” for minors. Reports show that there are nearly 30 such cases currently working their way through the courts in the U.S.
A key piece of testimony in Varian’s case came from her mother, who testified that her daughter’s psychologist insisted her 16-year-old would likely commit suicide if not allowed to proceed with this dangerous delusion. All too often we hear stories of parents being pressured with lines such as “would you rather have a dead daughter, or a living son?” This mother’s testimony shows that this disgusting pressure tactic is very real. The radical transgender lobby has long dismissed detransitioners’ claims of coercion, but there’s no hiding the truth.
This case exposes the systemic failures that many of us have come to recognize. Dangerous hacks with degrees are planting ideas and rushing children into life-altering decisions that profit providers but leave kids with permanent consequences. This verdict is likely to serve as a watershed moment, hopefully leading to dozens of similar malpractice victories. This is a welcome shift, especially when considered with the shift in policies across several states limiting this kind of so-called “medical care” to begin with. The tide is turning.
At PhyllisSchlafly.com, we will always provide you with the latest news and action items in the fight to save our children from radicals. Sign up for emails at PhyllisSchlafly.com and join us tomorrow for the Phyllis Schlafly Report.
