In our age of theological whim and church-brand shopping, it’s tempting to say: “I’m Christian, but I’m not…” — fill in the blank. I’m Christian, but not old fashioned. Christian, but not judgmental. Christian, but not bound by tradition. Yet what if Christianity is not about your brand but about truth revealed? The old Christian creeds exist to remind us exactly of that.
Nearly two thousand years ago, Christians gathered, debated, and insisted: these truths matter. They formulated the Apostles’ Creed and later the Nicene Creed. They did not invent new doctrine, they safeguarded revealed truth. When groups claimed new words from God or reinvented Jesus into their own image — someone had to say, “No.” That’s what creeds are for.
Today some call creeds outdated, or worse — tools of the powerful to suppress spiritual “freedom.” Secular critics say each creed was just another gate-keeping mechanism. But that’s not true. The creeds didn’t invent faith, they articulated it — they drew the line between historic Christianity and the fade-away of true belief.
Take the Apostles’ Creed: crafted around 150 AD in Rome (yes, earlier than you may realize), it set out what a new convert would confess: one Creator, Jesus named, Spirit referenced, resurrection anticipated. It distinguished authentic Christianity from pseudo-movements like Gnosticism, Marcionism — doctrines that denied the core of Christ. Then the Nicene Creed later clarified: Jesus is fully divine, not a lesser spirit. It confronted error within believing circles and kept the Church anchored.
So what do creeds do for us now? They act like boundaries for the house of Christian belief. As C.S. Lewis pictured in Mere Christianity: imagine Christianity as a house. The creeds mark the rooms. They show who’s in the Christian house and who is in another house entirely. That doesn’t mean we roll up dogmatic sleeves at every disagreement — but it does mean there are essentials we cannot discard without losing the faith itself.
In an era where every “Christian” can redefine Christianity to their liking, this is a conservative call: hold the line. Resist cultural pressure to water down doctrine. Speak the faith plainly. Protect the boundaries of what it means to follow Christ. Because when we blur the creed, we blur the gospel.
The creeds are not relics; they are means of clarity in chaos. They remind us not of what we think, but of what we believe. And if we forget that distinction — we risk building a Christianity of our own design, not the one revealed by Christ.
If you want to be a thinking Christian, join us at PhyllisSchlafly.com. That’s PhyllisSchlafly.com. Thank you and join us tomorrow for, the Phyllis Schlafly Report.
