Eagle Forum Education & Legal · A 501(c)(3) organization

Publications

Oregon Social Worker Fights Trans Books in Court

Photo by JACQUELINE BRANDWAYN on Unsplash

A seventeen-year veteran school social worker in Oregon named Roderick Theis [TICE] had three children’s books on display in his office. He is He. She is She. And Johnny the Walrus — conservative host Matt Walsh’s children’s book about a boy who decides he is a walrus. Three books celebrating biological truth — affirming that boys are boys and girls are girls.

A teacher walking past his office filmed students reading the books and filed a complaint with the district, calling them transphobic and classifying the display as a bias incident. This is defined under district policy as a hostile expression of animus toward another person’s gender identity. The district ordered Theis to remove the books and threatened termination if he repeated the offense.

Theis sued with the help of Alliance Defending Freedom, arguing the district violated his First and Fourteenth Amendment rights. His case made it all the way to the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals. He lost — two to one.

The majority ruled that because Theis was a government employee speaking in his official capacity, the school district had the authority to control his speech. The lone dissenting judge pointed out what the majority refused to acknowledge: that the same district openly permitted other ideological expressions throughout the building. Employees displayed pride flags. Teachers put up progressive messaging without consequence. Only Theis’s books triggered a bias investigation, a forced removal, and ultimately termination.

This is not a policy about keeping workplaces neutral. It is a policy about keeping one viewpoint out — now blessed by the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals.

ADF has stated it was evaluating next steps, which likely means a petition to the Supreme Court. The new term’s docket already includes significant religious liberty and free speech cases. This Oregon case fits squarely into the pattern of government employers selectively punishing viewpoints they disagree with while leaving favored radical expressions untouched.

This case established in the Ninth Circuit that a school employee can lose his job for displaying books that affirm biological sex, while colleagues face no consequences for displaying books and symbols that affirm the opposite view. This is censorship, plain and simple, enforced by a so-called public school and backed by a federal appeals court. We wish Thies and his legal team full speed ahead in their fight for free speech.

Stay informed on this case and many others at PhyllisSchlafly.com, and join us again for the Phyllis Schlafly Report.